This feature is currently in testing and may only be available to a limited number of users. Some functionality may change, and you may occasionally experience issues while we continue to make improvements.
Email Reply Tracking
Band Pencil allows you to automatically store replies from clients against their original emails, helping you keep track of conversations without having to search through your email inbox. When enabled, Band Pencil can record incoming client replies and link them to the original outgoing email, keeping your correspondence together in one place.
While it isn't intended to replace your normal email inbox, it makes it easier to refer back to previous conversations and keep important client communications together in Band Pencil.
Enabling Email Reply Tracking
To enable this feature:
- Log in to your Band Pencil account.
- Go to Settings.
- Find the Outgoing Email Options section.
- Tick Store email replies in Band Pencil.
- Save your settings.
Once enabled, Band Pencil will automatically include a unique tracking email address in the Reply-To field of supported outgoing emails.
How Does It Work?
When you send an email to a client through Band Pencil, a unique tracking email address is automatically included in the email's Reply-To field. This allows Band Pencil to receive incoming replies and identify which original email they belong to.
For example:
- You send an email to a client from an event in Band Pencil.
- Band Pencil automatically includes a unique tracking address in the Reply-To field.
- Your client receives the email as normal.
- Your client selects Reply and sends their response.
- Their reply is sent to Band Pencil's tracking address and automatically stored against the original email.
You can then view the original email and any recorded replies together in Band Pencil. Each tracked email has a unique reply address, similar to:
messages-a7f93b21c84d[at]bandpencil.com
This address allows Band Pencil to identify the original message and associate incoming replies with the correct conversation.
Manually Adding Replies to a Conversation
If a client starts a new email rather than replying to the original message or doesn't include the tracking email you can manually add their correspondence to an existing conversation in Band Pencil.
To do this:
- Open the original sent email in Band Pencil.
- Find the Reply email address displayed on the message page.
- Click the address to copy it.
- Open the client's email in your normal inbox.
- Forward the email to the copied address.
Band Pencil will receive the forwarded email and store it against the original conversation.
Always use the Reply email address displayed on the relevant message page. Each tracked message has its own unique address, ensuring correspondence is linked to the correct conversation.
Which Emails Are Supported?
Email reply tracking is currently available for:
- Client emails sent from an event: Emails manually sent to a client through the event page in Band Pencil (this includes scheduled emails)
- Lead Capture Form: Confirmation of submission to the lead capture form sent to the client.
- Client Page Emails: Emails sent from the client page.
Emails Not Currently Supported
The following emails are not currently included in reply tracking:
- Member emails: Emails sent to members.
- Other automated emails: Automatically generated emails, including reminders, notifications and other system-generated correspondence.
We may expand support to additional email types in future updates.
Viewing Email Conversations
When a reply is successfully received, Band Pencil automatically associates it with the original outgoing email. Open the original message in Band Pencil to view the Replies section, where you can see any responses that have been recorded.
This provides a useful reference when managing bookings, allowing you to review previous client correspondence without having to search through your email inbox.
You cannot respond to recorded replies directly from the Replies section. To continue a conversation, use your normal email provider or send a new email from the event page in Band Pencil.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I reply to clients directly from the Replies section in Band Pencil?
No. Email reply tracking is designed to keep a record of client correspondence for reference purposes, rather than replace your normal email inbox. You can view recorded replies in Band Pencil, but you will need to use your usual email provider to respond to them.
Do clients need to select Reply All?
No. The tracking address is included in the Reply-To field, so clients can simply select Reply in their email provider.
Will replies still arrive in my normal email inbox?
Yes. Your normal email address remains included in the Reply-To field alongside Band Pencil's unique tracking address.
What happens if a client starts a new email instead of replying?
If a client starts a completely new email, Band Pencil won't automatically know which existing conversation it belongs to. You can manually forward their email to the unique Reply email address displayed on the original message page to add it to the conversation.
Can I manually add an email to an existing conversation?
Yes. Simply forward the email to the unique Reply email address displayed on the relevant message page in Band Pencil.
Can I track replies to emails sent before enabling this feature?
No. Reply tracking only applies to supported emails sent after the feature has been enabled.
Are emails sent to members tracked?
No. Email reply tracking currently supports client correspondence only. Emails sent to members are not included.
Are automated emails tracked?
The default confirmation email sent when a client submits an enquiry is supported. Other automated emails are not currently tracked.